Contents
Reviews
A review record is the written result of attacking a project: factory step 5, done by someone trying to show the work is wrong. Each record names the repo and commit it looked at, the version of the bar it measured against, and the tools it used. It gives a status for each bar item and a list of findings. Each finding has a command or a source reference that reproduces it, the output seen, and a proposed fix. Evidence files sit next to the record and run against the named commit.
A review record is not a spec approval. Bar item 1 needs a person who did not write the specification to approve it. A record written by an AI agent, or by the author, can find problems. It cannot approve.
The brief’s rule is that “finding a spec error is a success to report, not a failure to hide” (“Risks and the plan for each”). Review records apply it to every problem they find.
Records
- tar/2026-10-24-bar-audit.md: the tar pilot at
7517a86. Not yet verified: the headline theorem states less than its claim, two statements under “What is not proved” on its page are false, and three of the six bar items are not fully met.